Great Big Beautiful Life: A Dissonance in Tone and Expectation
When Emily Henry’s latest release, "Great Big Beautiful Life," landed in my hands, anticipation buzzed through me like an electric current. Having devoured "Beach Read"—a charming yet genre-blurring read—I believed this book would further cement her status as my go-to author for beautifully crafted romances. Alas, my hopes were met with a disheartening reality: "Great Big Beautiful Life" turned out to be less of a romance and more of a puzzling literary distraction.
Right from the start, I was charmed by the premise: Alice, a quirky journalist, and Hayden, the brooding counterpart, are pitted against each other in the race to document the life of enigmatic heiress Margaret Ives. Their resulting interactions sparkled with potential. We could have had a delightful exploration of rivalries blossoming into romance, yet this tale quickly traded its romantic stakes for an exhaustive deep dive into Margaret’s lineage. It felt less like a love story and more like an overly documented biography.
Ah, the theme: the pursuit of a "great big beautiful life" began as a tantalizing hook but morphed into an exhaustive recount of Margaret’s family history, eclipsing Alice and Hayden’s budding relationship. I genuinely envisioned a charming rivalry leading to a poignant romance; instead, I trudged through chapters primarily dedicated to Margaret’s story, leaving scant room for the dynamic I was craving.
Henry’s prose remains undeniably beautiful, weaving words that leap off the page and pull you in. "When I let myself dream," whispers a breathless moment between Alice and Hayden, encapsulating their initial intimacy. Yet, as I read, a gap formed between their on-page chemistry and the reality of their relationship, especially as Alice suddenly declared her love with all the natural progression of a brick wall.
What added to my exasperation was the pacing. At points, I found myself captivated by Alice’s journalism adventures, but just when her character felt like it could truly shine, it was suffocated by side plots that didn’t serve the narrative. And the ending? Picture the tone of a cozy romance colliding head-on with a mystery thriller, leaving me bewildered. The abrupt shift to involve investigative elements felt slapdash and unrealistic, as if the author had tossed in plot twists to mask what was otherwise a hollow emotional landscape.
Despite my frustrations, I must reflect on the talent displayed here. Henry excels at crafting characters and dialogues that are witty and relatable. The setup had so much potential. However, there were far too many moments where those rich ideas were diluted by over-exploration of secondary plots rather than allowing Alice and Hayden to flourish as a couple.
In the end, I found "Great Big Beautiful Life" to be a classic case of unmet expectations. While it may find its audience in readers who savor literary fiction interwoven with themes of family and personal reflection, if you’re after a romance that ignites the pages, you may want to pause before diving in.
For those who loved the heartwarming connections in "Beach Read," this one may leave you longing for that spark. As for me? I’ll be over here, mending my heart, hoping for the magical mix of romance I know Emily Henry is capable of delivering. Maybe next time, right?
Discover more about Great Big Beautiful Life on GoodReads >>