Book Review: Powerless (Powerless #1) by Kira Jane Buxton
Ah, Powerless. It grabbed my attention with promises of a dark, thrilling romp through a world that fuses popular fantasy tropes into a new narrative. I think we’ve all been there — the anticipation of reading a “romantasy” that melds elements from our favorite reads. I was curious: could this debut novel from Kira Jane Buxton live up to its hype? Spoiler alert: while it’s a cocktail of familiar themes, it ultimately left me feeling just a tad disenchanted.
A Familiar Canvas
Powerless introduces us to Paedyn, our protagonist with more attitude than direction, and Kai, the tall, dark-haired, morally ambiguous love interest. The premise revolves around a kingdom in turmoil, a dash of forbidden romance, and trials that echo the likes of The Hunger Games and Red Queen. Lauren remarked that this was like “the child of The Hunger Games and Red Queen,” but honestly, I felt like I was reading a mash-up of a few too many of my old favorites without a fresh coat of paint.
The characters, while fun at times, tread very familiar ground. Paedyn’s supposed complexity often snapped into clichés — the unyielding underdog with a heart of gold who navigates a world that can’t decide if it prefers her as a rebel or a princess. Meanwhile, Kai delivers brooding aesthetics but practically evaporates under scrutiny. Their banter, though entertaining, came off as overly repetitive, sometimes making me wonder if I was reading a longer version of a Wattpad story gone awry.
Writing Style: A Double-Edged Sword
On the writing front, Buxton’s style has moments of brilliance, especially in its key emotional beats, but it often falls into an abyss of lengthy sentences that bogged down the narrative. I felt like I was trudging through the prose, desperately trying to glean deeper meaning from what was essentially poetic filler. For a debut, it’s ambitious, but an editor’s sharp eye could have trimmed the fluff.
It’s as if every sentence needed to be infused with metaphor after metaphor, so while attempting to sound profound, it sometimes just came off as convoluted fluff. Trust me, there’s a reason I’m shouting, "For the love of all that is holy, use an inhaler!" at these characters.
The Verdict
Despite my frustrations, there’s a charm that may keep younger readers engaged, especially those who enjoy stories rife with “enemies-to-lovers” tropes, secret stairways, and impulsive decisions. I could certainly see Powerless resonating within a fan base eager for romance and action without the added pressure of originality.
In conclusion, if you’re a reader who enjoys fantastical tales filled with familiar tropes, or you’re simply looking for a quick, easy read, Powerless might just hit the spot. However, if you’re on the hunt for a unique narrative or deeply developed characters, you might want to keep your expectations in check.
Ultimately, Powerless left me both amused and exasperated, a quirky experience that made me chuckle — even while rolling my eyes. Who knows? Maybe this is the perfect escapade for you to get lost in, assuming you’re ready to revel in the familiar and ignore the unoriginal. Happy reading!
Feel free to leave your thoughts below. I’d love to know if you found the book as infuriatingly charming as I did!
Discover more about Powerless (Powerless, #1) on GoodReads >>