Book Review: Murder by Memory by Olivia Waite
When I stumbled upon Murder by Memory, the first in the Dorothy Gentleman series, I was immediately drawn in by Olivia Waite’s intriguing premise: a locked-room murder mystery set aboard a spaceship with 10,000 inhabitants! As a fan of cozy mysteries, I had a flicker of doubt, wondering if this concept might buckle under its own weight. Still, I took a leap of faith, and I’m so glad I did—the story exceeded my expectations on every level.
From the moment we board the HMS Fairweather, it’s clear that this is no ordinary spaceship. Waite has crafted a delightfully cozy space that feels more like a friendly neighborhood than an impersonal vessel in the void of space. The descriptions of the ship’s libraries, cozy bars, and even yarn stores envelop the reader in a warm embrace. I found myself longing to explore Waite’s utopian society, a world where wealth is regulated, innovation is celebrated, and custodial roles are among the highest paid. Talk about a refreshing take! This setting didn’t just serve as a backdrop; it became a character in its own right, exuding comfort and community in a way that felt utterly enchanting.
At the heart of Murder by Memory lies a tantalizing exploration of identity and memory. I was captivated by the idea that our memories—those fragile recollections that shape us—can exist independently from our physical selves. The technology aboard Fairweather dazzles the imagination: memories can be downloaded into books, and when our bodies age, a new vessel can carry our consciousness forward. It raises profound questions: If memories define us, what does it mean to extend our existence? Waite deftly plays with this intriguing concept, delivering rich experiences that transported me straight into the minds of the characters.
Dorothy, our sharp-witted elderly detective, was another high point of the novel. Watching her rediscover the world through the lens of a younger body was heartfelt and humorous. Her delight in newfound sensations was infectious, making for a compelling perspective that I thoroughly enjoyed. It was a reminder that age need not define capability, and I appreciated how Waite portrayed Dorothy’s journey with depth and nuance.
Now, I must admit that I encountered a slight misstep with the ship’s cheeky AI. While I appreciate an injection of quirkiness, its semi-drunken banter felt a tad too twee against the otherwise cozy narrative. However, this minor quibble didn’t detract from the overall experience; in fact, it felt like a fun foil against the ship’s otherwise earnest environment.
Overall, Murder by Memory is a triumph for Olivia Waite. This book is perfect for fans of whimsical, heartfelt stories reminiscent of Howl’s Moving Castle or the works of Mary Robinette Kowal and Brenda Peynado. It’s a nourishing read that left me grinning and pondering long after I turned the last page. If you’re looking for a cozy, thought-provoking escape into a world of charming characters and clever mysteries, this delightful blend of science fiction and whodunit is not to be missed.
As I close the cover on this engaging novel, I find myself eagerly hoping for a return to Fairweather. For now, I’ll be recommending Murder by Memory to anyone ready to embark on an exhilarating, cozy adventure. Happy reading!
Discover more about Murder by Memory (Dorothy Gentleman, #1) on GoodReads >>